Either the Blonde Eyebrow Cream or Eyebrow Pencil! 

Thanks for your question. The Taupe Eyebrow Pencil with Spoolie is in stock. It is our number one selling pencil. The majority of our customers have asked us to create an Eyebrow pencil with Spoolie so we have discontinued the ones without. Thanks 

We recommend, for you, our Luscious light brown eyebrow color. It is a warmer shade not too red and not too dark

We consulted with our International makeup artist and she said: You would be a perfect candidate for our Light Brown! The blonde and taupe 
Both have some ash in them but our light brown is not ashy and very golden in tone. 

I am not an expert, and without seeing you that is a very hard question, but I think I would go with the natural color of your hair. I have red hair and I use the auburn.